“Westerns,” Pippin writes in Fatalism in American Film Noir, “adopt a mythic style of narration appropriate to founding narratives, presenting us. keen skills of textual analysis, Massood convincingly argues that the film is very much like his others, in that. 4 Little Girls includes “a focus on African American. Robert B. Pippin. Fatalism in American Film Noir: Some Cinematic Philosophy. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press x + pages. $ (cloth.

Author: Vurisar Bar
Country: Cuba
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Music
Published (Last): 21 March 2004
Pages: 244
PDF File Size: 14.34 Mb
ePub File Size: 19.63 Mb
ISBN: 921-6-55446-124-8
Downloads: 50016
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Tygot

Contact Contact Us Help. Some Cinematic Philosophy by Robert B. In this book Robert Pippin argues that many faatalism these films also raise distinctly philosophical questions. Request removal from index.

The Critical Practice of Film: Each of the next three chapters is an in-depth analysis of a particular film: Faalism marked it as to-read Dec 26, Skip to main content. Films do not merely tell a story, of course; they also display the story. Solomon – – Philosophy East and West 53 4: Terry Kuny added it Jan 28, I watched a lot of movies in grad school.

Yet in some sense they act, and fatefully. Robert Pippin has done it again. Fatalism in American Film Noir is a very welcome addition to the small but growing literature on philosophy in film, offering a highly literate, searching, and urbane traversal of three outstanding films from that genre, intelligently interrogated for their bearing on philosophical questions about the nature of the self, action, responsibility, and fate.

Pippin also reminds that we and characters are never just subjects, but also objects. Matt Barletta rated it liked it Jun 18, Like tragic figures, the heroes of noir are, or seem, doomed from the start.

VamanaBhava Ruse rated it it was amazing Jun 15, For example, in the opening of Out of the Past Pippin points out a bunch of overlapping relations between “seeing” and “hearing” and the truth: Pippin skillfully demonstrates that complex relations among ideas such as those of action, character, intention, self-control, and self-knowledge are undeniably part of the content of these strangely gripping cinematic tours de forceas is more overtly, the idea that the main characters in these claustrophobic scenarios are in some sense fated to do what they do.


Fatalism in Philosophy of Action. Hardcover amfrican, pages.

Fatalism in American Film Noir: Some Cinematic Philosophy

This is the confession of someone who simply cannot see the world as it is, but only as he feels or imagines it. Renan Virginio marked it as to-read May 09, And then he suggests that what noir films – at least the three he analyzes – show is exactly that: On the other hand, fate serves characters as a ready-to-hand, always available justification for failing to act as they know they probably could and should.

Orde marked it as to-read Nov 17, King marked it as to-read May 14, Tim marked it as to-read Nov 25, Seamlessly blending philosophy, history, and film analysis, it convincingly and powerfully suggests that the crucial function of film noir is to offer a worked-out picture of what life would look like were we to suspect that our most important decisions carry no real weight.

Where most Hollywood films of that era featured reflective individuals living with purpose, taking action and effecting desired consequences, the typical noir protagonist deliberates and plans, only to be confronted by the irrelevance of such deliberation and by results that contrast sharply, often tragically, with his or her intentions or true commitments.

Some Cinematic Philosophy Robert B. Daspit rated it really liked it Sep 25, Cross at one point tellingly remarks, “that’s one thing I could never master, perspective”. Merleau-Ponty and Carroll on the Power of Movies. Ratalism boy tending the gas station is a deaf-mute and we learn quickly that Jeff alone in the town can understand sign language, can hear by seeing, in other words, instead of what we will learn to suspect people in the town do, see only what they hear.

The Ways of Film Studies: I went to screenings for a class on Ophuls that Miriam Hansen taught, I watched all the Westerns that Pippin screened in Doc Films that led to his Westerns book, and I watched both The Lady from Shanghai and Out of the Past in the big lecture theater in the Social Science building at Chicago when Pippin was screening them for this book. Susi Ju rated it it was ok Mar 15, This slim volume is essentially a detailed and nuanced philosophical examination of three classics of American film noir, all from the very fateful ‘s: Whereas Bailey and O’Hara, fitfully in thrall to the femmes fatales of Out of the Past and Amrican from Shanghai wmerican, are partially opaque to themselves, and wrestle faatalism opposed feelings and desires, the feelings moir desires that drive Cross are unqualified, not inherently opposed, and as transparent as can be.


In two recent books Robert Pippin has offered a compelling nooir unique contribution to this philosophical project through fiml seemingly modest path of examining two genres that flourished in midth century American film: Rethinking Ideology in Cinema.

Robert B. Pippin, Fatalism in American Film Noir: Some Cinematic Philosophy – PhilPapers

Secular Magic in a Rational Age. The crime melodramas of the s known now as film noir shared many formal and thematic elements, from unusual camera angles and lighting to moral ambiguity and femmes fatales. I note some missed opportunities in the book in light of both the specific cinematic repertoire it examines and its undisguised entry in the film-as-philosophy sweepstakes, though they do little to dim the book’s overall success.

Pippin’s analysis highlights the way in which the films chosen for examination give credence to the existentialist idea that persons are ultimately defined through amefican actions, however ostensibly motivated, fataliism than through the beliefs, thoughts, or rationales that may precede action.